You bought a beautiful bunch of cilantro on Monday, and by Thursday it is a slimy green puddle in the crisper drawer. It happens to everyone, and it is almost never your fault. Fresh herbs are living plants, and most of us store them the exact way that kills them fastest. The fix is simple, cheap, and takes about two minutes. Learn the two herb families and how each one wants to be treated, and you will waste less money and always have something green to finish a dish.

The two herb families (and why storage differs)

Almost every herb you buy falls into one of two camps, and each one wants the opposite thing.

  • Tender herbs have soft, thin stems and delicate leaves: cilantro, parsley, basil, mint, dill, and chives. Think of them as cut flowers, because that is basically what they are. Trim the stems, stand the bunch in a jar with about an inch of cool water, and drape a produce bag loosely over the leaves so they keep a little humidity without suffocating. Most (parsley, cilantro, dill, mint) are happy in the fridge this way. Change the water when it looks cloudy, usually every couple of days. Clean water is what keeps them alive, and done right, parsley and cilantro can stay crisp for two weeks or more.
  • Hardy herbs have woody stems and tougher leaves: rosemary, thyme, sage, oregano, and marjoram. These are not thirsty. Wrap them loosely in a slightly damp paper towel, tuck that in a bag or container, and store it in the fridge.

Match the herb to the method and you have won most of the battle.

The basil exception

Basil is the diva of the group. It comes from warm climates and hates the cold, so the fridge turns it black and sad within a day. Treat basil like a countertop bouquet: trim the stems, put it in a jar of water, and leave it on the counter out of direct sun. No bag on top, since basil likes airflow. Refresh the water every day or two and pinch off any leaves that start to darken.

Wash smart, and revive the wilted

For herbs you will use within a few days, storing them dry is safest, since water clinging to leaves speeds up rot. Just give them a quick rinse right before you cook.

For a longer hold, wash first and then dry thoroughly. Swish them in a bowl of cool water, lift them out, and spin or pat them completely dry. A salad spinner is ideal, but a clean towel works. The rule is simple: moisture on the leaves is the enemy, moisture at the stems is the friend.

And do not toss a floppy bunch too soon. If the leaves are wilted but not slimy or yellow, they are just thirsty. Trim the stem ends, stand them in a glass of cold (even ice) water, and give them 15 to 30 minutes in the fridge. Most tender herbs perk right back up.

When you have way too much

Bought a giant bunch or your garden went wild? Do not let it rot. The smartest habit costs nothing: buy or grow only what you will actually use. A small living pot of basil or mint on the windowsill gives you leaves on demand, and buying less more often beats composting half a bunch. When you do end up with a surplus, preserve it:

  • Freeze in oil. Chop the herbs, pack them into an ice cube tray, top with olive oil, and freeze. Pop a cube straight into a hot pan later. This works beautifully for hardy herbs and for cilantro and parsley.
  • Dry the hardy ones. Rosemary, thyme, oregano, and sage dry well. Hang small bundles somewhere warm and airy, or use a low oven, then crumble the leaves into a jar.
  • Tender herbs lose their punch when dried, so freezing is the better call for those.

Quick chart: which method for which herb

  • Jar of water, in the fridge, loosely covered: parsley, cilantro, dill, mint, chives
  • Jar of water, on the counter, uncovered: basil
  • Damp towel, wrapped, in the fridge: rosemary, thyme, sage, oregano, marjoram
  • Freeze in oil cubes: cilantro, parsley, basil, and any hardy herb
  • Air-dry or low oven: rosemary, thyme, sage, oregano

Frequently asked questions

How do I store cilantro and parsley?

Treat them like flowers. Trim the stems, stand the bunch in a jar with about an inch of water, drape a loose bag over the leaves, and keep it in the fridge. Change the water every couple of days and they will easily last one to two weeks.

Should basil go in the fridge?

No. Basil hates the cold and will turn black fast. Keep it on the counter in a jar of water, out of direct sun, uncovered so it gets airflow. Refresh the water every day or two.

Can I freeze fresh herbs?

Yes, and it is the best way to save a surplus. Chop them into an ice cube tray, cover with olive oil, and freeze. Drop a cube into a hot pan when you cook. Hardy herbs also dry well, but tender herbs keep their flavor better frozen than dried.

Why do my herbs get slimy so fast?

Trapped moisture on the leaves plus stale water is almost always the cause. Store use-soon herbs dry, keep the jar water clean and fresh, and give the leaves a little airflow instead of sealing them in a tight, wet bag.

House Home Decors may earn a commission from purchases made through our links, at no extra cost to you.